A listening exercise I like to give my mixing students is a comparison of the two canonical mixes of The Stooges’ Raw Power - the 70s “Bowie Mix” and the redone 90s “Iggy Mix.” I think it’s a useful prompt for a couple reasons: first, it makes it very clear what the mix is actually doing - these two versions sound pretty different in ways that are not hard to hear. Second, the comparison never fails to start a debate about which of the two actually sounds better. There are credible arguments for either, but the bottom line is that both of them have serious problems.
David Bowie’s original mix features a famously thin-sounding rhythm section that frequently gets buried by Iggy’s vocals and James Williamson’s guitar overdubs. Apparently Bowie’s hands were kind of tied, and some of that balance was baked into the tracks he was given. A couple decades later, Iggy went back to the album to see if he couldn’t “solve” some of the mix’s legendary “problems.”
I of course encourage you to form your own opinions about these two mixes, but my take is: yeah, Iggy’s mix made some changes that can be considered improvements - the instruments and voice generally feel more balanced, and there’s some real low-end in the bass - but it has new, unique problems that are hard to ignore. That added bass weight generally comes at the expense of clarity (it’s bigger without really being better). The 90s mix is less shrill than the 70s mix, but in my opinion it overcorrects to the point of being a bit “wooly,” and crucially, it trades a flawed-but-dynamic mix for a slammed, loudness-war-era mix that hangs out in the red too much for its own good. For what it’s worth, I prefer the Bowie mix (and apparently so does Iggy), even if things about it bug me.
Here’s the thing though - what I think really doesn’t matter, because this album’s legacy (undeniable classic, duh) was cemented long before the remix, in spite or because of its flaws. You might prefer the Iggy mix - and that’s a valid opinion! - but it’s not like people suddenly realized “oh huh, this is a good record” in 1997.
Raw Power is an extreme example, but I stand by this takeaway: many great recordings have obvious problems. Some of your favorites probably have qualities that, on paper, seem like flaws, but that you wouldn’t want to change for anything. Sometimes it’s the things that make a record sound “wrong” that also make it sound like itself.
This doesn’t mean I’m encouraging you to make recordings that sound “bad” - in fact, I plan to continue writing about ways you can make them sound better and better. What it does mean is that I’d like to remind you that “good sounding” recordings are measured by the way they make the audience feel, not by loudness standards or spectrum analyzer readings. A recording feeling right beats “perfection” (whatever that is) ten times out of ten.
Go make your music your way, and share it with anyone that wants to hear it. Forget the haters.